▲ Chautauqua Local
Claim your business
Home › Mayville › Restaurants › Andriaccio's Restaurant
Andriaccio's sunset patio on Chautauqua Lake
⭐ Featured ✓ Verified · May 2026 Patio season opens May 15
"Homemade Italian on Chautauqua Lake since 1982."

Andriaccio's Restaurant

★★★★☆ 4.5 (586) ·● Closed · opens Wed 11am ·$$ Italian · Lakefront
Family-owned since 1982Italian15+ pizza varietiesOutdoor patio Lakefront sunsetReservationsTakeoutCatering
📞 (716) 753-5200 🍕 Order online 🌐 andriaccios.com 📍 Get directions
📞 Call 📍 Directions 🍕 Order
Overview Menu Offers Photos Reviews Location
👑

Andriaccio's pulls 586 reviews and shows 8 signature dishes. You show your phone number.

Mayville visitors comparing dinner spots tonight see Andriaccio's sunset patio cover photo, the Cinghiale pizza, the Shrimp Portofino, and 44 years of family ownership. They see your address. Where do you think the table goes?

Sunset patio cover photo + circular logo
Full menu with photos & signature dishes
Active offers (patio season, holiday hours)
Top sort priority on Mayville restaurant searches
Reservation + online-order CTAs
$297 / year · less than $25/month

About Andriaccio's

Family-owned Italian restaurant on Chautauqua Lake's western shore. Hand-tossed pizza in 15+ varieties, homemade pasta, slow-roasted entrées — recipes Sally Andriaccio has been making since 1982.

Andriaccio's has been serving the Chautauqua community and visitors since 1982. The restaurant specializes in homemade Italian cuisine plus excellent American food: pasta, seafood, steaks, chicken, veal and vegetarian selections, and more than 15 varieties of gourmet pizza. Sally still walks the floor most nights.

Cinghiale Pizza$22
White sauce, fig preserves, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, arugula, balsamic glaze, olive oil. Signature.
Shrimp Portofino$26
Fresh linguine, grilled shrimp, mushrooms, spinach, toasted pine nuts, lemon-butter cream sauce. Most ordered.
Coppola Pizza$24
Capicola, salami, sausage, bacon, roasted peppers, multiple cheese blend.
Margherita Pizza$16
Garlic oil, fresh imported mozzarella, vine-ripened tomato, organic basil.
Homemade Lasagna$22
Layers of seasoned ricotta + ground beef, mozzarella, Romano. Choice of Alfredo or marinara.
Carbonara$22
Linguine, egg cream sauce, crispy pancetta, peas, garlic, shaved parmesan.

See full menu →

Lake season

Outdoor patio season opens May 15

Sally's signature lakefront sunset experience returns. Outdoor bar service Wed–Sun.
Walk-ins welcomeThrough Sep 30

Photo gallery

+2 more

Amenities

✓ Outdoor sunset patio
✓ Outdoor bar
✓ Reservations
✓ Takeout
✓ Catering available
✓ Family-friendly
✓ Vegetarian options
✓ Full bar

Reviews

4.5
★★★★☆
586 reviews
Google + TripAdvisor + OpenTable
5
422
4
105
3
41
2
12
1
6
TB
Tom B.
5 days ago · Mayville, NY
★★★★★

Have been coming for 30 years. The Cinghiale pizza is the reason. Sally still walks the floor most nights — that's how you know it's still good.

Imported from Google
SW
Sarah W.
2 weeks ago · Erie, PA
★★★★★

Drove down for an anniversary dinner. Patio at sunset over the lake, Shrimp Portofino, a bottle of Chianti. Couldn't have been better.

Imported from OpenTable

Recognition

🍕
Best Italian on Chautauqua Lake
Chautauqua Local Editors 2025
👨‍🍳
44 years · same family
Sally Andriaccio, owner-chef since 1982

About this listing

Where is Andriaccio's located?
4837 W Lake Rd., Mayville, NY 14757 — on Chautauqua Lake's western shore.
What are Andriaccio's hours?
Closed Mon–Tue. Open Wed–Sat 11am–9pm and Sunday 11am–8pm. Outdoor patio runs Memorial Day through end of September.
Is Andriaccio's verified on Chautauqua Local?
Yes — Featured (paid) listing claimed by the owner. Last verified May 6, 2026.